Rule 4-3, Damaged clubs: Repair and Replacement

[aaa]

Whilst having some sympathy for the young lady in Johanna's tournament, I would be more concerned that a change would remove a significant disincentive to young (and old for that matter) players from poor behaviour. Throwing or slamming clubs must be discouraged. An etiquette penalty is too remote (a single incident on the 17th would not incur a penalty). There must be an immediate consequence. Taking the club out of play fits the bill.